Spotting Quality in Handmade Sterling Silver Jewelry

Sterling silver is a blend of 92.5% pure silver and 7.5% alloy metals, typically copper, to enhance durability. Look for hallmarks or stamps like “925” or “Sterling” on the piece, which indicate genuine sterling silver. Be cautious of terms like “silver-plated,” as these are not solid sterling silver and may tarnish or wear quickly.

2. Examine Craftsmanship

Handmade jewelry should showcase meticulous attention to detail. Inspect the piece for:

  • Smooth finishes: No rough edges or unfinished areas.

  • Secure settings: Stones or embellishments should be firmly in place.

  • Symmetry and balance: The design should feel harmonious and well-proportioned. Imperfections are natural in handmade items, but they should add character, not detract from the piece’s overall quality.

3. Feel the Weight and Texture

Sterling silver is relatively dense and should have a satisfying weight in your hand. Lightweight pieces might indicate hollow or substandard materials. Additionally, the surface should feel smooth and polished, with no flaking or irregularities.

4. Assess the Design and Uniqueness

One of the joys of handmade jewelry is its originality. Quality pieces often feature unique designs that reflect the artisan’s creativity and skill. Look for thoughtful details and innovative styles that stand apart from mass-produced alternatives.

5. Understand the Materials

Artisans often use high-quality materials like natural gemstones, premium beads, or ethically sourced elements to complement the sterling silver. Ensure these materials are well-integrated into the design and match the advertised descriptions.

6. Ask About the Artisan’s Process

Don’t hesitate to ask the maker about their techniques, inspiration, and materials. Passionate artisans are usually happy to share their story and explain how their pieces are made. This not only helps you verify quality but also deepens your connection to the jewelry.

7. Look for Tarnish Resistance

While sterling silver naturally tarnishes over time, high-quality pieces may include finishes or coatings to slow this process. Check with the artisan about any treatments used and learn how to care for the piece to maintain its shine.

8. Read Reviews or Testimonials

If you’re purchasing online or from a new artisan, reviews and testimonials can provide insights into the quality and customer satisfaction of their work. Positive feedback from other buyers is a good indicator of reliability.

9. Evaluate the Price

Handmade sterling silver jewelry requires time, effort, and premium materials, so it’s often priced higher than mass-produced alternatives. If a piece seems too inexpensive, it might not be genuine sterling silver or could compromise on craftsmanship.

10. Trust Your Instincts

Finally, trust your instincts. Quality jewelry should resonate with you—it’s not just about aesthetics but also how the piece makes you feel. If something feels off, take a closer look or explore other options.

Final Thoughts

Spotting quality in handmade sterling silver jewelry ensures you’re investing in a piece that will last for years and hold sentimental value. By paying attention to details, materials, and the artisan’s craftsmanship, you can confidently select a timeless treasure that speaks to your style and supports skilled artisans.

Back to blog